Reading the other reviews, I noticed some guests had rather negative remarks. My wife and I did not experience any of this. The directions Carmel gave us were very clear and we were at the hotel about five minutes after exiting the train station on foot. One guest, who seemed a bit upset, said the directions led him to a... more

This review is about a year late but the memories of this great little hotel is still very fresh in my memory due to the wonderful time we had there. Hotel Il Bargellino is located close to Florence's main train station, its Duomo, Accademia, Palazzo Medici and other sites. It's perfectly situated location made the our visit to Florence all... more

My husband and I have just recently returned from a month long tour of Europe. Our last stop was Florence - which we spent six days and six nights. Pinot and Carmel made us feel welcome and allowed our group - there were 19 of us - to have nightly gatherings on the Terrace. The room my husband and I... more

My husband and I just returned from two weeks in Italy. We loved Hotel Il Bargellino. The room was much larger than those we had at either the two-star hotel in Rome or the three-star in Venice. The hosts, Carmel and Pino, were very friendly. Our room was on the terrace-side of the hotel, so we did not have the... more

The hotel is quaint with a lovely terrace and nice hosts, but seemed as if this place was more geared towards americans, with some surprise at guests that are not americans (i.e. us). This is probably due to the american wife of the owner couple. Unfortunately this made the hotel seem less diverse, whereas Florence is very diverse!! The rooms... more

My husband & I stayed at Il Bargellino this past April. This a lovely hotel situated conveniently near the train station. Carmel and Pino are wonderful hosts. The hotel was clean, decorated authentically, and within walking distance to everything. more

El Bargellino was a small, pleasant typically old time European hotel but it was noisy both inside and out. The street noise, nearly all night, was incredible and the sounds on the inside carried to all the rooms. Pino and Carmel need to replace the windows with some sound deadening ones so their guests can get some sleep and they... more

my wife and i stayed at the hotel in march and it was very romantic, very clean and very close to the train station and all the attractions florence had to offer. You can walk everywhere from the hotel just grab a map and have carmel show you where all the important sites are. very nice terrace to hang out... more

my daughters and i were greeted with open arms on the day of out arrival. the room was warm and charming.we went to italy to visit my son who is studing in florence for the semester. the hotel was very convientent to him and most of the sights we were interested in seeing. one of the afternoons my daughters were... more