Villa Taina Hotel can be summarized simply: good (not great but certainly not bad) quality rooms, good food (though no room service, which would be so easy to do given cheap labor costs), and good service, but the pricing is set for "great" vs. good in all of these categories. Also, the breakfast buffet has gotten stingier, with small things like raisons and cinnamon for the oatmeal now gone vs. prior years.
The manager Franz is a good mannered host, and he seems to hire well. However, much of the staff has gone from very friendly years ago to robotic (at best). The guy making omlettes every morning seemed angry, never smiling and somewhat resentful that we had come to him for something to eat. The waiters were somewhat better, though at times the "standing around doing nothing" routine (vs. checking on tables) got old.
The rooms were so/so to good (for DR standards; bad if you are used to international hotels with non-plastic, flimsy toilet seats and cheap fixtures like at the Taina). It really depends on your standards. However, will tell you for sure that the price/room is way above what the average quality/room delivers. Taina has raised prices (in US$ and Euros) mightily over the past five years, where now a $40-50 room from a few years ago goes for $80-90/night. I must note that this is not due to the devaluation of the peso here, as the hotel prices everything in dollars but probably pays the staff in pesos (making a case for their prices being even more excessive given the devaluation of the peso).
For business travelers, one saving grace is the Internet connection. Broadband speeds and on 24/7, including in the room price. This alone made the hotel worth our staying as we were working on/off during our stay. However, the Agualina Kite Resort reportedly has similar pricing, great Internet and amazing new rooms. I'll be staying there the next time just so I get quality facilities for the money. When Franz decides to spend some of his massive profits refurbishing the rooms, especially the "penthouse" rooms (all three should be combined into two penthouses as they are too small for the money), I'll be back.
TFO
This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC.